Lost in individualism

Lost in individualism

by Deleted user -
Number of replies: 1

I will be bit more specific to primary care work in discussions about screening and assessing risk.

The simple meaning of screening is taking history and examining the patient for the possible diseases and try to mitigate the risk of a serious pathology. It is not uncommon to say’’ I do not know what it is but unlikely to be serious’’ to reassure patient. There is always a ''false negative'' risk as there is with any other screening tests.

Screening in case of supposedly healthy population is also a common domain of general practice as part of preventive medicine rather than problem solving aspect of medicine.  Taking example of cardiovascular disease , the more people recognised earlier and intervened , the longer or better quality of lives obtained. Hence there is high ride on ‘’check-ups’’ and promote healthy lifestyle. However, I feel   that in some way we shift responsibility onto patient to react on hazards and move away from the government providing psycho-social aspect of health. How often we find obesity as the single contributing factor for increased risk of HT, CVD and diabetes for example which is called modifiable in the medical field but surely not so for the patient.  On the one hand, surrounded by take-away shops offering quick and cheap meals and on the other  gyms with expensive membership fees, these patients are left with fear of the direct and indirect complications of obesity that is reiterated at each consultations with doctors: ‘’Your blood pressure, diabetes, arthritis and depression will improve if only you loose weight.’’ I am doubtful  if articulating the degree of risk increases the motivation while the strategies in tackling the problem is lacking.

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Lost in individualism

by Sara Shaw -

Preventative medicine really lends itself to thinking about risk doesn't it!

There's lots in here. Your point about the constraints that people face (e.g. price of gym membership) when trying to change is well made and really important. Your post also made me wonder about of risk communication.... might people respond differently to calls to lose weight if risk was communicated differently? There's lots in the literature on risk communication, but I have in mind a study that explored the effect on smoking quit rate of telling patients their lung age (Parkes et al, 2008). Its perhaps different from the obesity example (?) but showed an increase in quit rate as a result of communicating information differently. What they couldn't explain is...... why?

 

Parkes G, Greenhalgh T, Griffin M and Dent R (2008) Effect on smoking quit rate of telling patients their lung age: the Step2quit randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal 336: 598.